eBay vs Shopify: Selecting the Ideal Solution for Your Business

Table of Contents

Get the latest e-commerce industry news, best practices, and product updates!

Reading Time: 8 minutes

To realise e-commerce success in Australia, choosing the most suitable platform for your online business is a decision of extreme importance. The right platform can help you increase the visibility of your online store, attract the right kind of buyer and empower your business to flourish, while an ill-fitting choice could hinder your growth and success. 

This article delves into a comprehensive comparison of two leading e-commerce platforms in Australia, eBay and Shopify, providing you with the insights necessary to make an informed decision. Whether you’re a seasoned entrepreneur entering the Australian market or an aspiring e-commerce enthusiast wanting to create an online store and sell, this analysis will guide you towards the platform that best aligns with your unique business needs and aspirations.

Understanding Your Business Needs 

Embarking on the e-commerce journey requires a clear understanding of your business’s distinct requirements. Before diving into platform comparisons, it’s crucial to assess your unique needs and aspirations. Begin by identifying the effort you are going to put into the platform. If you want to build a store, manage your entire e-commerce website and tend to personalise the entire shopping experience – Shopify is an ideal choice.  If you’re focusing on only listing your products and the selling aspect, eBay is the one you should opt for. 

Next, define your target audience. Who are you selling to? What are their demographics, interests, and online behaviour? Tailoring your platform choice to your target audience will ensure a seamless and engaging user experience.

Finally, consider your business’s scalability goals. Do you envision rapid growth and expansion? Or do you prefer a more gradual approach? Choosing a platform that can accommodate your anticipated growth trajectory will prevent you from outgrowing its capabilities. By carefully evaluating these factors, you can narrow down your platform options and select the one that best aligns with your business’s unique roadmap.

eBay vs. Shopify: Feature comparison

A comparison chart can often be helpful in guiding individuals to make the right decision. We wish to take that responsibility off your shoulders. Therefore, here’s a detailed comparison of eBay and Shopify based on the specified criteria:

Active users135 million yearly2.1 million daily
Pricing plans and feesFree to list, insertion fees, transaction fees, and store subscription feesMonthly subscription fees, transaction fees, and credit card processing fees
Payment processing optionsPayPal, credit cards, and debit cardsShopify Payments, PayPal, and over 100 other payment gateways
Inventory managementBasic inventory management toolsAdvanced inventory management tools, including product variants, inventory tracking, and barcode support
Marketing and SEO capabilitiesLimited marketing and SEO toolsBuilt-in marketing and SEO tools, including a blog platform, email marketing tools, and social media integration
Ebay plus and Shopify plusPremium membership program with additional benefits, such as free shipping and returnsPremium membership program with additional benefits, such as dedicated account support and access to exclusive apps and features
Customer support24/7 customer support24/7 customer support
CustomizationLimited customisation optionsExtensive customisation options, including custom themes, fonts, and layouts

eBay: Pros and Cons

While eBay has a fairly small audience when compared to other platforms, it can be an incredibly useful platform -especially for individuals looking to get the best rates on pre-loved items. Here are a few more of the benefits of selling on eBay:

  • Large and Established Customer Base: eBay boasts a massive global customer base of over 139 million buyers, providing sellers with immediate access to a vast audience of potential global customers. This extensive reach significantly increases the likelihood of making sales, especially for new or niche businesses.
  • Ease of Use for Beginners: eBay’s user-friendly interface and straightforward listing process make it an ideal platform for beginners venturing into e-commerce. The platform’s intuitive design and comprehensive seller resources simplify the setup and management of an online store, enabling even those with limited technical expertise to establish a successful presence.
  • Built-in Trust and Reputation System: eBay’s established reputation system, seller protection programs, and seller feedback mechanism foster trust and confidence for sellers to use the platform.,. The platform also has policies to prevent abusive and fraudulent buying behaviour.  Additionally, eBay also has policies to instil trust in buyers that reduce the hesitation often associated with making online purchases from unfamiliar vendors.

Nevertheless, eBay can pose limitations for certain buyers. Listed below are some of the disadvantages of eBay as a platform to sell new and pre-owned items.

  • Limited Branding and Customization Options: eBay’s structured marketplace environment restricts the extent to which sellers can personalise their storefronts. While some customisation is possible, the platform’s overall design and layout remain largely standardised, limiting opportunities for unique branding and differentiation.
  • Transaction Fees and Listing Fees: eBay charges various fees associated with selling on the platform, including insertion fees, transaction fees, and store subscription fees. These fees can accumulate, potentially reducing profit margins, particularly for sellers with high-volume or low-margin products.
  • Competing with Other Sellers: eBay’s highly competitive marketplace can make it challenging for sellers to stand out from a vast pool of competitors. With numerous sellers offering similar products, differentiation and effective marketing strategies become crucial for attracting buyer attention and securing sales.

Shopify: Pros and Cons

Now that we have taken a look at the pros and cons of using eBay as an e-commerce platform. Let us dive into the benefits and limitations of selling on Shopify. 

Shopify is known for being a no-hassle, simple, and easy-to-use platform. But it has many other hidden benefits. Some of the advantages of using Shopify have been listed below:

  • Full Control Over Your Online Store: Shopify grants sellers complete ownership and control over their online stores. Unlike marketplaces like eBay, Shopify allows sellers to customise their storefronts, manage their inventory, and implement their own marketing strategies without limitations or restrictions. This autonomy empowers sellers to create a unique brand identity and tailor their online presence to their specific business goals.
  • Customisation Options: Shopify offers a vast array of customisation options, enabling sellers to create a visually appealing and brand-consistent online store. From selecting themes and layouts to modifying fonts, colours, and product images, Shopify provides the flexibility to create a unique and personalised shopping experience for customers.
  • Diverse Range of Features and Apps: Shopify’s extensive app store boasts thousands of apps, empowering sellers to enhance their online stores with a wide range of functionalities. These apps can streamline operations, automate tasks, and provide valuable insights, allowing sellers to focus on growing their business and improving customer satisfaction.

Like most things,  Shopify also has its drawbacks and may not appeal to all types of sellers. Read ahead as we look at the cons of using Shopify as an online selling platform:

  • Monthly Subscription Costs: Unlike eBay’s listing fees, Shopify requires sellers to pay monthly subscription fees to maintain their online stores. These fees can vary depending on the chosen plan, ranging from $29 to $299 per month. While Shopify offers a 14-day free trial, ongoing subscription costs can be a consideration for sellers with tight budgets.
  • Requires More Technical Expertise: While Shopify’s user-friendly interface simplifies store setup and management, some level of technical expertise is beneficial for maximising the platform’s capabilities. Understanding basic HTML, CSS, and liquid coding can open up more advanced customisation options and enable the implementation of complex features.
  • Building and Growing Your Own Customer Base: Unlike eBay’s established customer base, Shopify sellers need to actively attract and retain customers. This may involve implementing effective marketing strategies, optimising product listings for search engines, and providing exceptional customer service to build a loyal customer base.
  • Installing third-party apps: As an e-commerce seller, you are responsible for driving your own traffic to your Shopify store and converting them. While Shopify may have marketing and customer conversion tools, they may be limited in terms of functionality. To offer an engaging experience on your Shopify store, you may have to install third-party apps which again may incur additional costs.

Closing Thoughts

Navigating the e-commerce landscape can be a daunting task, but with careful consideration of your business needs and aspirations, you can select the platform that best aligns with your goals. While eBay and Shopify offer distinct advantages, sellers don’t have to choose between them. 

Moreover, utilising the services of a 3PL provider like Locad, which offers multi-channel selling capabilities, allows you to leverage the strengths of both platforms simultaneously. By seamlessly managing your inventory and orders across multiple channels, 3PL providers can streamline your operations and boost your overall sales potential.

Which platform is easier to use for beginners?

eBay is generally considered easier to use for beginners thanks to its simpler interface and seller resources. Shopify, while still user-friendly, offers more customization options, which can require some technical knowledge.

Which platform offers more control over your brand?

Shopify offers significantly more control over your brand than eBay. With Shopify, you can customize your storefront, product pages, and marketing materials to create a unique brand identity.

Can I sell on both eBay and Shopify?

Yes, you can sell on both eBay and Shopify simultaneously. This is called multi-channel selling and can be a great way to reach a wider audience and increase sales.

Which platform is better for building brand awareness?

Shopify is better for building brand awareness as it gives you more control over your online store’s branding and marketing. eBay’s marketplace environment makes it more challenging to stand out from other sellers.

Experience fulfillment by LOCAD

Grow your business through Locad’s simplified and automated fulfillment solution

  • Unlimited and scaleable warehousing
  • Pay only for what you store
  • No hidden fees or lock-in periods
  • Zero inbound costs
  • Wide integration with marketplaces
  • Automated logistics and delivery
Get the latest e-commerce industry news, best practices, and product updates!

Don't miss out on the latest news!

Get the latest industry news, best practices, and product updates!

Up to $250K USD Credits for Locad Customers!

Sign up today and accelerate your growth with Locad’s Partners. Unlock deals across SaaS, Agencies and more.

Exclusive benefits to ace your e-commerce game this 2023 with Locad’s desk calendar!